Every January I get people constantly coming to me with the same concerns and questions.
“I look soft...”
“My weight shot up...”
“I feel bloated and puffy...”
“I have not trained in two to three weeks....”
“...Should I start cutting now?”
Without fail, every single year people ask if they should start cutting as soon as the holidays are over, and every year my answer is the same.
You do not need to start a diet immediately after the holidays.
What you are seeing in the mirror and on the scale is rarely all true fat gain. It is a temporary reflection created by the holidays where you are eating all the tasty foods, your sleep is off, alcohol is more abundant, training is inconsistent, travel is constant, and you are generally living like what most people would call a regular person for a few weeks. That is not a failure. That is life.
The problem is not that people enjoy the holidays. The problem is how they respond afterward. The solution is not panic dieting or knee jerk reactions. The solution is giving yourself time to stabilize and refocus.
If you want to get back to your normal look and feel, you do not need to slash calories, jack up cardio, or start some aggressive mini cut. You need to return to your normal routines around food, sleep, and training.
Let’s walk through what is actually happening in your body and why the less extreme option is almost always the smarter one.
You are holding a ton of water
Over the holidays you eat foods you do not normally eat. They are higher in salt, higher in carbohydrates, higher in fat, and generally far more calorie dense.
You may have overeaten. That part is real. But you did not gain five pounds of fat overnight after Christmas dinner.
What happened is that your body stored a lot of extra water, both inside and outside of muscle tissue. Carbohydrates bind water inside the muscle cell. Sodium pulls water outside the muscle cell. When both go up together, scale weight spikes very quickly.
This is why someone can be up six pounds in three days without having eaten nearly enough calories to actually gain six pounds of fat.
That water weight also makes you look softer. Your skin looks a little puffier. Your midsection feels thicker. It creates the illusion of fat gain even though it is mostly fluid.
Your stomach is literally fuller
You are eating more food volume than normal. That food does not disappear the moment you swallow it.
More food means more digestive content sitting in your system. That can easily add a couple pounds to the scale and make your pants feel tighter even before we talk about body fat.
This is one of the most overlooked contributors to post holiday weight gain. You are not only holding more water. You are physically carrying more food in your digestive tract.
Your muscles look flat
Missing a few weeks of training does not magically erase your muscle, but it does change how that muscle looks.
When you are not lifting, glycogen storage drops. Glycogen is what gives muscle that full, firm, round look. Without it, your delts lose their pop, your arms look smaller, your chest looks deflated, and everything just looks smoothed over.
It is incredibly easy to interpret this as fat gain. In reality you just lost your training pump look. So why not just cut immediately?
This is where people get themselves into trouble.
The issue with cutting immediately is not a physiological one most of the time. It is psychological. People see the scale jump up. They look in the mirror and feel soft. Their pants feel tighter than they did two weeks ago. They freak out and feel like they screwed everything up.
So they drop calories hard, maybe throw in cardio, and go full bore without thinking it through.
Now hunger and cravings spike. Training feels terrible. They feel flat and weak in the gym. They run out of gas quickly and convince themselves they lost a ton of muscle in just a couple weeks off.
This often leads to frustration and unnecessary yo yo dieting where they bounce between cutting and trying to regain what they think they lost.
The plan does not fail because they lack discipline. It fails because they are trying to fix something that is not actually broken.
Reframe the purpose of this phase
Instead of starting a hard diet in January, I like to use what I call a reset phase.
This is usually two to four weeks of eating at maintenance while you run a mesocycle focused on reestablishing your normal training routine.
Not cutting. Not bulking. Just resetting.
No crazy diets. No extreme cardio plans. No punishment.
Just return to baseline.
Why this works so well
This approach works because it allows your body to stabilize.
When carbohydrates and sodium normalize, water weight starts to come down. The scale drops. Bloating fades. Your midsection tightens up.
As you train again, glycogen returns to muscle. Your delts fill out. Your arms look tighter. You start looking like yourself again.
If you lost any muscle during time off, muscle memory allows you to regain it quickly, especially at maintenance calories. Trying to rebuild tissue while slashing calories just makes that harder than it needs to be.
Most people go into January wanting to look like they did before the holidays. When you give yourself a chance to stabilize, most people find that by the end of the month they are already back there or very close. Without ever dieting.
When it actually makes sense to cut
Once your bodyweight has stabilized for about a week and your training performance feels normal again, then reassess.
Not emotionally. Objectively.
Ask yourself if fat loss is still necessary or if normalization already solved most of the issue.
If fat loss is still appropriate, now you are dieting from a stable place. Hunger is lower. Recovery is better. Strength is higher. Results come faster.
The real takeaway
Post holiday weight gain and softness do not mean you failed or lack discipline. Being able to enjoy the holidays is part of making fitness sustainable long term.
The solution is not extremes. It is routine.
Do not panic. Do not make emotional decisions. Stabilize first. Then move forward.
Find more from Trevor on…
Instagram: @Trevorxgage